Are Items Stolen During a Move Covered by Insurance?
Usually not by your movers. Your home policy's personal property coverage may apply, but check whether it covers belongings in transit.
Free to compare
Where theft during your move stands
Your homeowners policy covers personal property it insures against theft, and that protection generally follows your belongings even when they're outside the house, including while they're being moved. The mover's own liability, if they offer any, is usually limited to a small amount per pound and won't come close to replacing what was taken. So the first place to look is your own policy's personal property section, and specifically whether it covers theft from a vehicle or in transit, since some policies limit or exclude that. Check your declarations page for the personal property limit, usually a percentage of your dwelling coverage, and for sublimits on jewelry, cash, or electronics, since those categories are often capped far below what you'd need to replace them. A police report and a list of what was taken, ideally with receipts or photos, will support any claim.
If what was stolen includes jewelry, electronics, or other high-value items, the sublimit on your policy could leave most of the loss uncovered no matter how strong your documentation is. Comparing policies now shows which ones offer higher sublimits or let you schedule specific items for their full value, which matters more for a move than almost any other time.
How to document a loss and get it paid
Start with a police report, even if you doubt anything will be recovered. Insurers generally ask for one before paying a theft claim, and the report date and description of what's missing become the backbone of your claim file. File it with the department where the theft happened, which for a move might be your old address, your new one, or a stop in between if items were taken from a truck or car along the way.
After that, write down everything you believe was stolen, as specifically as you can. Model numbers for electronics, approximate purchase dates and prices, a description of jewelry pieces including any stones or engravings. Receipts help, but most people don't have receipts for everything they own. Photos of the items, even ones taken years ago for other reasons, credit card statements showing the purchase, appraisals for jewelry, or a home inventory you made before the move all count as evidence. If you walked through your house with a phone camera before packing, that footage can settle questions about what existed and its condition.
Your insurer will apply your personal property limit and any sublimits to what you're claiming, then subtract your deductible from what's left. If the stolen items were electronics worth a few thousand dollars, a typical personal property limit absorbs that without trouble. Jewelry is where claims go sideways, because many policies cap jewelry theft at a figure like $1,500 or $2,000 total, regardless of what the pieces were worth. If you had a schedule, a separate line on your policy listing a specific item and its appraised value, that item is paid out at its full value instead of being squeezed into the sublimit. Scheduling is something you do before a loss happens, not after, so it matters most as something to set up before a move rather than something to reach for afterward.
One more detail worth checking is whether your policy pays replacement cost or actual cash value. Replacement cost pays what it takes to buy the item new today. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation, so a five-year-old television or laptop pays out at a fraction of its original price. Your declarations page or policy booklet will say which one applies to your personal property coverage, and it changes the payout by a lot on anything that isn't new.
What if the mover was responsible for the theft
If the items were stolen because of something the moving company did, left the truck unlocked, failed to show up when promised, hired someone who took things, there may be a second place to look besides your own policy. Movers that cross state lines are required to offer some level of liability coverage, though the baseline version pays by weight rather than value, often around 60 cents per pound, which turns a stolen 10-pound box of jewelry into a payout of a few dollars. If you were offered and paid for full value protection when you booked the move, that coverage works differently and is worth checking against what was actually taken.
Filing against the mover and filing with your home insurer aren't mutually exclusive, but they do affect each other. If the mover pays out something, even a small amount, that payment typically gets subtracted from what your home insurer owes, since you can't collect twice for the same loss. Most people start with whichever claim is more likely to pay promptly, often the home policy, and pursue the mover separately if the home insurer's sublimits left a gap. Keep paperwork from both conversations. An insurer will often ask whether you've also filed with the mover, and a denial or lowball offer from the moving company is itself useful evidence of how little that coverage actually covers.
Timing matters more than it seems like it should. Movers that operate under federal rules typically require a claim within nine months of delivery, and some set shorter windows in their own paperwork, so check the bill of lading or moving contract for a specific deadline rather than assuming you have months to sort it out. Home insurance claims don't usually have a hard deadline in the same way, but insurers expect to be notified promptly once you discover a loss, and waiting weeks to report a theft can itself become a reason a claim gets questioned.
None of this changes what belongs on the declarations page before a move happens. A home inventory, photos of valuables, and a schedule for anything irreplaceable are worth doing regardless of who ends up paying, because the paperwork that proves a loss is the same paperwork whether the claim goes to a mover, an insurer, or both.
Before the next move
Pull your declarations page and check the jewelry and electronics sublimits now, not after something's missing. Scheduling a valuable item takes minutes and pays its full value if it's ever stolen.
