Personal Property Coverage
It pays to repair or replace your belongings after theft, fire or other covered damage, up to your policy's limit.
Free to compare
Theft away from the house is usually covered too, so a laptop stolen from your car or a bag taken on a trip counts, often at a reduced percentage of your limit. Jewelry, cash, firearms, and collectibles have their own caps, often a few thousand dollars total, well below what the rest of your belongings are covered for. Your declarations page lists those caps. For a claim, you will need to show what you owned, so photos, receipts, or an inventory made before the loss matter more than anything written here.
Those caps are worth a second look
If your jewelry or electronics are worth more than the cap on your policy, that gap is yours to cover unless you schedule those items. Comparing policies shows which ones set those limits higher.
How do you schedule a high-value item
Scheduling means listing an item by itself on your policy, usually with a value set by a receipt or appraisal, instead of letting it fall under the category cap. Once it's scheduled, that ring or that guitar is covered for its own stated amount, not the few thousand dollars the policy sets aside for all jewelry or all musical instruments combined. Most insurers also drop or lower the deductible on scheduled items, so a scheduled item damaged or lost often gets paid from the first dollar.
An appraisal is usually required for anything with real value, jewelry especially, and insurers often want it updated every few years since gemstone and metal prices move. A recent receipt can stand in for an appraisal on something newer, like a camera or a musical instrument, as long as it shows what you paid. Keep a copy of whatever you submit. If you ever need to make a claim, that same document is often what settles it.
Scheduling also tends to widen what is covered. An unscheduled ring is covered for theft or fire like the rest of your belongings, but a scheduled one is often covered for accidental loss too. A ring that slips off in a lake or down a drain is covered where it would not be otherwise. That difference matters most for things people lose by accident rather than have stolen, like rings, watches, and loose stones.
Not everything worth scheduling is obviously valuable. Bikes, cameras, and computers are stolen often enough that some policies list separate caps for them even though they are not jewelry, and those caps can be just as limiting as the ones on a diamond ring. If you own one or two items that would be expensive to replace outright, check the cap on their category against what you paid for the item. Scheduling adds something to the premium, but it is usually small next to the value of the item itself, and comparing policies will show which insurers price that add-on lower.
What actually happens when you file a theft claim
The insurer pays out based on your policy's valuation method, which is either replacement cost or actual cash value. Replacement cost pays what it takes to buy the item new today. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation, so a five-year-old television gets paid out at what a five-year-old television is worth, not what a new one costs. Most homeowners policies default to replacement cost for personal property, but check your declarations page, since some older policies or lower-cost options still use actual cash value.
Filing the claim starts with a list of what was taken or damaged, as specific as you can make it. Brand, model, approximate age, and where you bought it, for every item. This is where a home inventory earns its keep. A folder of photos taken room by room, or a video walking through the house narrating what's there, holds up well when memory alone would not. Receipts help most for big-ticket items like electronics and furniture, since they fix the price and the date. For older items without a receipt, a photo showing the item in use at your house, dated by whatever else appears in the frame, is often enough.
The insurer may ask for a police report for a theft, and in most cases it's worth filing one even if recovery is unlikely. It documents that a crime happened, which is different from documenting what was lost, but insurers often want both. Keep the report number handy for the claim. If the theft happened away from home, like from a car or a hotel room, say so plainly when you file, since that's what triggers the off-premises coverage and its reduced percentage of your limit.
After the claim is filed, an adjuster reviews what you've submitted against your policy's limits and caps. Items under a category cap, like unscheduled jewelry, get paid up to that cap regardless of what you can prove they were worth beyond it. Items you scheduled separately get paid at their stated value, which is one more reason the scheduling conversation matters before anything happens, not after.
Before anything happens
Pull your declarations page and check the caps on jewelry, electronics, and anything else worth more than a few thousand dollars. Photograph what you own, room by room, and keep receipts or appraisals somewhere other than the house itself.
