What Counts as Evidence After a Break-In?
A police report, photos of the damage, and proof you owned what's missing, like receipts, bank statements, or old photos.
Free to compare
Building your claim after a break-in
Start with the police report, since most insurers require one and it fixes the date and details early. Then list what's gone, room by room. Back up the list with anything that shows you owned it, like receipts, credit card statements, photos where the item appears in the background, manuals, or appraisals for jewelry. If you have a home inventory with photos or video taken before the break-in, that carries the most weight. For older items without receipts, a reasonable estimate of age and original cost is usually accepted. The insurer may also ask for serial numbers on electronics. Without proof of ownership, the adjuster has nothing to value, so the claim either stalls or pays out at a reduced amount.
Jewelry and valuables have limits worth checking
Standard personal property coverage caps what it pays for jewelry, cash, and similar items, often a small fraction of what a stolen piece is worth. A quote can show what it costs to raise that limit before you need it.
What if you can't find a receipt for something that was stolen
A missing receipt doesn't automatically sink a claim. Insurers know most people don't keep paperwork for a television they bought six years ago or a watch they got as a gift. What they're looking for is something that supports your claim of ownership and value, and that can take several forms. A bank or credit card statement showing the purchase works even without the original receipt. A photo from a birthday or holiday where the item sits in the background of the shot works too. So does an old insurance appraisal, a warranty card, or an email confirmation from an online order.
For items with no paper trail at all, you can usually give a written estimate of when you bought it and what you paid, adjusted for age. The adjuster may ask how you arrived at that figure, so think about it honestly rather than rounding up. A five-year-old laptop isn't worth what it cost new, and most policies pay either its depreciated value or its replacement cost new, depending on what your policy specifies. Check your declarations page for which one applies, since it changes what a claim like this is worth.
Serial numbers matter more than people expect, especially for electronics. If you registered a product with the manufacturer, or if the box or manual is still in the house, the serial number is probably on it. Some insurers cross-check stolen serial numbers against pawn shop and resale databases, which can also help recover the item itself, not just the claim payout. If you photographed the back of a laptop or the inside of a watch case at any point, even by accident, that photo now has a job to do.
The strongest position is the one you set up before anything happens. A home inventory, even a simple video walking through each room and opening drawers and closets, gives you a timestamped record of what you owned and what condition it was in. Some people redo this once a year, or after any big purchase. It takes twenty minutes and sits in cloud storage until the day it's the only proof you have.
What counts as evidence when nothing was stolen but something was damaged
A break-in doesn't always end with things missing. Sometimes the door frame is split, a window is broken, or furniture got knocked over and cracked while someone searched the house. That kind of damage needs its own evidence, separate from the list of stolen items, and it's easy to forget in the moment because the missing items feel more urgent.
Photograph the damage before anything gets cleaned up or repaired, even if that means leaving a mess for a day while you deal with the police and the insurer first. Wide shots that show the damage in context, plus close-ups of the specific break, both matter. If a door was forced, a photo of the splintered frame along with one of the whole doorway helps the adjuster understand what happened and estimate what fixing it will cost. The same goes for a broken window, a kicked-in panel, or a pried-open lock.
Get a repair estimate even if you haven't decided whether to use that contractor. An estimate written on paper, with a name and a number attached, carries more weight than a verbal quote or your own guess at the cost. If the damage is to something structural, like a doorframe or a load-bearing fixture, this estimate may also matter for how fast the claim moves, since insurers sometimes treat structural damage with more urgency than damage to contents. Keep any receipts from temporary fixes too, like a board over a broken window or a locksmith called the same night, since those costs are often reimbursable as part of the claim.
Dwelling coverage is what pays for this kind of damage, not personal property coverage, which is the part that covers the stolen items themselves. They're separate coverages with separate limits on most policies, so a break-in that both damages the house and empties a drawer of jewelry can involve two different parts of the same claim. Your declarations page shows both limits, and knowing them ahead of time makes it clearer what the insurer is likely to cover and where the gaps might be.
Before anything happens
Check your declarations page for jewelry and valuables limits, and see whether personal property pays replacement cost or actual cash value. A quick inventory, even a phone video of each room, is worth doing tonight.
