What Is Not Considered Personal Property?
Structures, land, vehicles, and anything permanently attached to the house fall outside personal property. Those are covered elsewhere, or not at all.
Free to compare
Why your claim came back lower than you expected
Personal property coverage pays for things you'd pack if you moved. Furniture, clothes, electronics, dishes, all of that counts. But most policies cap certain categories separately, and this is usually where a theft claim falls short. Jewelry, watches, and furs often have a sub-limit around $1,000 to $2,500 total, no matter what your overall personal property coverage is. Cash, coins, and collectibles have their own low caps too. If what was stolen falls into one of these categories, check your declarations page for the exact sublimit, since it varies by policy. Items kept in a car are usually covered under home insurance, not auto, but the same category limits still apply. A scheduled endorsement, listing a specific ring or watch with its own appraised value, removes that cap for that item.
Find out what a scheduled item would actually cost to insure
If jewelry or other valuables pushed past your policy's sub-limit, scheduling them is the fix. Comparing quotes shows what that added coverage costs before you decide it's worth it.
What else falls outside personal property coverage
Land itself is never covered, by personal property or anything else. If erosion or a sinkhole damages the lot, that's a different problem than a claim. The same goes for anything a court would call part of the real estate rather than your things. Built-in appliances, cabinets, light fixtures, a fence, a shed bolted to a foundation all fall under dwelling coverage or the separate structures part of your policy. They're treated as part of the house itself, not as things you own.
Vehicles are excluded too, including cars, motorcycles, and most trailers. A car stolen from the driveway is an auto insurance claim, not a homeowners one. This splits in a way people don't expect. A bike stolen from the garage or a laptop stolen from the back seat of the car counts as personal property, because the policy covers the item, not the vehicle it happened to be sitting in or near.
Business property kept at home has its own limit, usually low, often a few thousand dollars total. If you run a shop out of your garage or keep inventory in a spare room, a standard homeowners policy was never built to cover that at full value. A business owner's policy or a rider fills that gap. Pets aren't personal property either, legally or on the claims form. A stolen or lost pet isn't something homeowners insurance pays out on, though some policies offer unrelated liability coverage if a pet injures someone.
Property belonging to someone else living in the house can get confusing after a break-in. A roommate's or adult child's belongings usually aren't covered under your policy unless they're a listed insured or related to you in a way the policy defines, so check who the declarations page actually names. Identity theft and the cost of replacing stolen cards, a passport, or a driver's license aren't personal property losses either, even when the theft happened alongside a burglary. Some policies add identity theft coverage as a separate endorsement, but it isn't part of the standard personal property payout.
How to prove what you owned after a theft
A claim for stolen property needs proof of what was there before it was gone. Insurers call this substantiating the loss, and without it they'll pay less than the claim is worth or push back on it entirely. A home inventory is the clearest way to do this. Photos or a video walking through each room, receipts for bigger purchases, and serial numbers for electronics all help. Keep copies somewhere other than the house itself, since a cloud folder or email survives a burglary or a fire in a way a printed list in a drawer doesn't.
For jewelry or other high-value items, an appraisal matters more than a receipt. A receipt shows what something cost when bought. An appraisal shows what it's worth now, and an adjuster will ask for one before paying out anywhere near a sub-limit. This is also the document a company needs to schedule an item in the first place, so getting it appraised does double duty.
When nothing was photographed or saved, a claim isn't automatically denied. Credit card statements, old photos where the item happens to appear, or a written statement from someone who saw it can support a claim, though the payout may come in lower without stronger proof. Police reports help establish that a theft happened, but they don't establish value. The adjuster still needs some way to price what was taken.
Someone who hasn't made an inventory yet doesn't need to start from scratch. A quick pass through each room with a phone camera, narrating what's there, covers most of what a claim would ever need. Valuables worth scheduling are worth photographing up close, with the appraisal paperwork kept alongside the photo. Updating this after a big purchase takes a few minutes and saves an argument later.
Before you need it
Check your declarations page for the jewelry and valuables sub-limit, then compare it to what those items are actually worth. If they're worth more, see what scheduling them would cost.
