What to Do if Your Gun Is Stolen from Your Home
File a police report first, then file a claim. Coverage usually applies, but firearms often have a low sublimit unless scheduled.
Free to compare
Your stolen gun and the claim that follows
A stolen firearm falls under personal property coverage, but most policies cap theft payouts for guns, often around $2,500 total, no matter how many you owned or what they were worth. That cap applies whether it's one rifle or a collection. If your guns are worth more than that, the gap only closes by scheduling them, listing each one on your policy with its own value, usually backed by an appraisal or receipt. After a theft, the police report becomes part of your claim file. The adjuster will also ask for proof of ownership, such as receipts, photos, a purchase record from the dealer, or an appraisal if you have one. Without that, you're relying on your memory and whatever documentation you can still find. Check your declarations page for the firearms sublimit before you assume what's covered.
Find out what your policy actually caps
Firearms sublimits vary by insurer, and some policies offer higher limits or easier scheduling than others. Comparing policies shows whether a better fit exists for what you own.
Reporting the theft to federal authorities
Filing a police report is the first step, but a stolen firearm also needs to be reported to the ATF. Federally licensed dealers keep records of serial numbers at the point of sale, and that number is what ties a recovered gun back to its owner. If you kept the original box, manual, or purchase paperwork, the serial number is probably on it. If you don't have it, the dealer who sold it to you may still have the record on file, and it's worth calling to ask.
Local police may also ask for the serial number when you file your report, and having it ready speeds up both the police report and the insurance claim. A gun recovered later, whether by your local department or through a national database, is far more likely to make it back to you if the serial number was on record. Without it, a recovered firearm is just an unclaimed object in an evidence room.
An adjuster weighing a payout on a firearm with no receipt, no appraisal, and no serial number is working from your word alone. A serial number doesn't replace a receipt or appraisal, but it adds another piece of proof that the gun existed and was yours. For anyone who owns firearms, keeping a simple list of each one, its serial number, what it cost, and a photo costs little. It matters a lot if the worst happens.
Some states also have their own reporting requirements for lost or stolen firearms, separate from what the insurance claim needs. These vary by state and sometimes by city, and the rules can include a deadline for reporting after you discover the theft. The police officer taking your report can tell you whether your state requires this and what the process looks like. None of this affects whether the policy pays out, but skipping it can create problems that have nothing to do with insurance.
Scheduling firearms so the payout actually covers them
If what you own is worth more than the sublimit, scheduling is the only way to close the gap. Scheduling means listing each firearm on your policy individually, with its own value attached, rather than letting it fall under the general personal property cap. Once scheduled, a gun is covered up to the amount listed, not the few thousand dollars most policies set aside for firearms as a category.
Insurers usually want something behind the value you're claiming. A receipt from the dealer works. So does an appraisal from someone qualified to give one, which matters most for older guns, collectibles, or anything without a clear purchase price. A photo helps but isn't proof of value on its own. If you own several firearms, an appraiser can often value the whole collection in one visit, which is simpler than tracking down paperwork for each one separately.
Scheduling adds a small amount to the premium, usually a percentage of the item's value each year, and the exact rate depends on the insurer and sometimes the state. In exchange, theft, loss, and sometimes accidental damage get covered at the full scheduled amount, without the firearms cap applying. Some policies also drop the deductible for scheduled items, so a claim pays from the first dollar rather than after you've covered part of it yourself.
Not every gun needs scheduling. A single hunting rifle worth a few hundred dollars probably sits comfortably under most sublimits already. It starts to matter once the value of what's stolen could exceed that cap, whether that's one valuable firearm or several ordinary ones added together. Checking the replacement value of what's owned against the number on the declarations page is the way to find out which side of that line it falls on.
Before anything else happens
Pull up your declarations page and find the firearms sublimit, then add up what your guns are worth. If the total is higher, scheduling them is worth a look.
